Mexican cave skeleton reveals secrets of New World’s first people


Handout of divers Nava and Bird transporting a skull to an underwater turntable for photographing in an underwater cave in Mexico's Yucatan Peninsula
Handout of divers Nava and Bird transporting a skull to an underwater turntable for photographing in an underwater cave in Mexico’s Yucatan Peninsula Credit: Reuters/Paul Nicklen/National Geographic/Handout via Reuters


(Reuters) – Scientists said on Thursday genetic tests on her superbly preserved remains found by cave divers have answered questions about the origins of the Western Hemisphere’s first people and their relationship to today’s Native American populations.

These findings determined that the Ice Age humans who first crossed into the Americas over a land bridge that formerly linked Siberia to Alaska did in fact give rise to modern Native American populations rather than hypothesized later entrants into the hemisphere.

Scientists exploring deep beneath the jungles of Mexico’s eastern Yucatán peninsula discovered the girl’s remains underwater alongside bones of more than two dozen beasts including saber-toothed tigers, cave bears, giant ground sloths and an elephant relative called a gomphothere.

The girl – with her intact cranium and preserved DNA – was entombed for eons in a deeply submerged cave chamber before being discovered in 2007. The petite, slightly built girl – about 4 feet, 10 inches tall (1.47 meters) – is thought to have been 15 or 16 years old when she died.

She may have ventured into dark passages of a cave to find freshwater and fallen to her death into what archeologist James Chatters of the firm of Applied Paleoscience, one of the leaders of the study, called an “inescapable trap” 100 feet (30 meters) deep – a bell-shaped pit dubbed Hoyo Negro, “black hole” in Spanish.

Chatters said the chamber – more than 135 feet (40 meters) below sea level – was “a time capsule of the environment and human life” at the end of the Ice Age.


The divers named her “Naia,” a water nymph from Greek mythology. One of the divers, Alberto Nava, recalled the moment Naia was spotted – her skull resting atop a small ledge. “It was a small cranium laying upside down with a perfect set of teeth and dark eye sockets looking back at us,” Nava said.

The pit was dry when she fell but Ice Age glaciers melted about 10,000 years ago, inundating the caves with water. Tests determined she lived between 13,000 and 12,000 years ago.

Scientists long have debated the origins of the first people of the Americas. Many scientists think these hunter-gatherers crossed the former land bridge between 26,000 and 18,000 years ago and subsequently pushed into North and South America starting perhaps 17,000 years ago.

But the most ancient New World human remains have confused scientists because, like Naia, they have narrower skulls and other features different from today’s Native Americans.

This led to speculation that these earliest New World people might represent an earlier migration from a different part of the world than the true ancestors of modern Native Americans.

But mitochondrial DNA – passed down from mother to child – extracted from the girl’s wisdom tooth showed she belonged to an Asian-derived genetic lineage shared only by today’s Native Americans.

This indicates cranial and other differences between the earliest New World human remains and today’s Native Americans are due to evolutionary changes that unfolded after the first migrants crossed onto the land bridge, the researchers said.

The study, led by the Mexican government’s National Institute of Anthropology and History (INAH) and supported by the National Geographic Society, appears in the journal Science.

(Editing by Matthew Lewis)